May 3, 2016

Phil Robertson has the Same Rights as You


I recently wrote an article about Phil Robertson’s suspension from Duck Dynasty. To summarize the article, Phil, as the patriarch of the family, was suspended by A&E from the show because he made a comment that was not in favor of homosexuality in an interview with GQ magazine in their January issue. Immediately after the issue was published, an uprising of commotion grew on social media and on broadcast programs.

The article I previously wrote gives only the facts about the situation, as I carefully intended. However, I do have a strong opinion on the matter, which I thought to separately express.

Being an avid Duck Dynasty fan, I was very disappointed when I heard the news. Phil is one of my favorites of the Robertson clan. I have always admired his commanding presence and his calm demeanor. As I was researching his interview, I read his comment, and I will admit that I was a bit shocked at how gutsy it was. There are certain things that you do need to be careful about when expressing them to the public. However, I do not believe he violated anything by expressing his religious beliefs.

Phil comes from a very conservative, God-fearing family that was thrust into the limelight. A&E knew this when they were first approached with the idea of featuring the Robertsons in a reality television show. The genre of the show itself is called “reality.” If A&E is not able to handle some of its biggest stars having an unpopular opinion, they should not have done the show in the first place.

It was Phil’s First Amendment right to express his religious views. Nowhere in the First Amendment does it say that a person’s views need to be popular or favorable to everyone, nor does it say that you cannot express your opinion if it is to a large audience. We all hear or read other people’s opinions regularly that may or may not offend us. That does not mean that they should be punished. It does mean that we need to grow a backbone and let them practice their human right to have an opinion. Did A&E have the right to suspend Phil? Yes, they did. However, I cannot agree that their action to suspend him was morally sound. I do have an issue with the media respecting the left’s right to have their own opinion and beliefs, but nobody else’s.

The argument has been made that Phil should have been sensitive to the fact that he is in the limelight, and his private opinions should be kept private. While I can understand where those who express this opinion are coming from, they need to understand that Phil’s private life has already been on screen for the whole world to see. As soon as he was made a reality television star, his private opinions naturally became everybody’s business. That is how the media works these days.

One of the biggest parts of Phil’s life, besides his family, is his religious beliefs. It is a well-known fact that the Bible lists homosexuality as a sin. That this is listed in the Bible is not a prejudice or a political statement, but a fact. All Christian religions believe in the Bible, to one extent or another. Everybody who watches Duck Dynasty knows the Robertsons are devout Christians. Christianity believes homosexuality is a sin, but the sinner is not necessarily a bad person. Christianity also preaches to hate the sin, but love the sinner. Our world today has been conditioned to jump and scoff at the first sign of “prejudice,” without first understanding what the person in question is really saying.

If this television show featured a liberal family, their personal views would have been spewed across the screen and praised by the media. However, because this family represents and expresses traditional values, and because they represent the silent majority of America that stays out of the limelight, they are harshly punished.

Phil should have been more careful about what he is saying, being mindful of his audience. However, he was not wrong in the principle of expressing his opinion. He did not preach hate to all homosexuals. He did not say death to all homosexuals. He did not attack anybody, nor did he ever intend to.

This is not about gay rights. When it comes down to the bare bones of the matter, this issue actually has nothing to do with gay rights. This whole predicament does have everything to do with a man and his right to express his religious beliefs without being punished for it by society, as well as the dire need for society to grow thicker skin and face the reality that not everybody is going to share your same beliefs. Whether you agree with him, whether I agree with him, or whether your neighbor agrees with him does not make Phil’s First Amendment right any less valid.

Conservatives have to take punches every single time they tune into on their TV’s. Liberals should be able to do the same. Not everybody will have the same opinion as you or agree with your lifestyle. Just like Phil had every right to express his religious belief, you can agree to disagree, and civilly continue standing for your own beliefs.


326 Responses to “Phil Robertson has the Same Rights as You”
  1. Is there a copyright or anything on content in Youtube videos?

  2. I have a site, and my content is protected with a Creative Commons license, but I want to copyright it so places like eBaums World doesn’t steal my content. How can I get my entire site copyrighted?.

  3. michael says:

    The is pro genocide, pro rape. What a ignorant person you are. Sorry but if you really understood the Bible Chapter and Verse. Then yiu would realize its teachings of Love, acceptance. Its history to guide away fro evils. And most importantly Dicernment. After the History of old testament , the new testament gives us Life, repentance, and Forgiveness fir our sins. That’s right we are not perfect, we sin. We forgive. The problem her is Leftist or progressives want to tell you how to think and believe. Its ok to speak your opinion. We should di that more and what kind of Society we really have. My beliefs may not be yours, if I cannot reconcile them with my Gods word , the go your way and I will go mine. But dont tell llis of deceictfullness, Sodom, and kill babies calling it choice, and say my wayis bad. Did you know under Obama the US destroys 1 million babies a year. And that is under our Government Education system call health and welfare. What are we doing to ourselves. Think about those things Robertson is righteous is in his speech.

  4. Doc_brown says:

    I find this hilarious. Phil absolutely has the right to free speech. No one has tried to take that away from him. A&E is a business. They have the right to pull people off of their network who threaten their business model or, who they just don’t want to broadcast that message.

    As far as Phil and the bible. He is, like most bible readers, ignorant of what the bible actually says. Most modern Christians want to pick and choose what they will and will not follow. New Testament over Old etc..

    If he, and all Christians, followed what the bible actually says, they would have concubines, slaves, and their wives would only speak when spoken to among other things… Worshiping the bible as an a perfect document is also a sin (idolatry).

    The bottom line is that the New Testament was assembled from hundreds of books by a committee. That committee’s goal was to preserve the power of the church of Rome and create some continuity in the story line of Jesus’ life and deeds. It is not a perfect document. As evidenced by the hundreds of edits that have occurred over the years.

    Reading a flawed book, holding it up as perfect, creating a ridged personal ethos which condemns others based on that flawed documents is actually, according to the bible, a mortal sin.

  5. michael says:

    Yeah right on. Talk about thin skin where is the lefts skin. More like foreskin I bet. I am a believer in my bible. So I have been listening to some arrogant lefties. Every year we are supposed to swallow there bile. Just be happy. I SAY no more. Let us feed them there own retoric like Sarah Palin endores and listen to them cry foul. What a laugh. Really thin skin I think. Poor baby did Robertson hurt your feelings. OMG a fav saying for non believers when things go wrong or someone dies. Listen to the hypocropsy now. They call many of us names that I wont use in front or behind my children. HBO is a prime example. Its not entertainment to disguise religious racism. Sexual explicit and abuse of Women. The name calling and unapolegetic morons. The problem is we just turn our heads and forgive and pray for them. Ok I struggle with there forgiveness. But I still them as Americans and my Family is Multiculteral and Dicrrnmrnt is tough. They cry because we can deny them under GOD and Say WhatEver. That Chaps their a**. I mean their lips

  6. Henry says:

    What amazes me is how a small minority of this supposedly offended group keeps saying that surveys or poles are showing that a vast majority of Americans are in favor of homosexuality. This is a pure propaganda LIE! These people will do or say anything to advance their agenda and their version of Tolerance is, “Your to be tolerated as long as you agree with with them!” God Bless Phil Robertson!

  7. The pilotman says:

    Well said Jeff.. It certainly appears religious hypocrites don’t understand this.

Check out what others are saying...
  1. Title…

    [...]that may be the finish of this write-up. Right here you will locate some websites that we think you’ll enjoy, just click the links over[...]…

  2. Superb website…

    [...]always a big fan of linking to bloggers that I love but don’t get a lot of link love from[...]……

  3. Title…

    [...]The facts talked about inside the article are a number of the top accessible [...]…

  4. Title…

    [...]usually posts some very interesting stuff like this. If you are new to this site[...]…

  5. click site says:


    [...]just beneath, are various entirely not connected websites to ours, nonetheless, they’re surely worth going over[...]…

  6. massage says:

    Recent Blogroll Additions……

    [...]usually posts some very interesting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[...]……

  7. Great website…

    [...]we like to honor many other internet sites on the web, even if they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[...]……

  8. Casino says:

    Gems form the internet…

    [...]very few websites that happen to be detailed below, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[...]……

Leave A Comment

!!! Comments that do not adhere to our guidelines will not be published. !!!

 characters available